Paul Scholes & Roy Keane Reveal What Man United Must Do This Summer Transfer Window

Manchester United legends Paul Scholes and Roy Keane have weighed in on the club’s critical summer plans, warning that Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the Red Devils’ hierarchy must make tough decisions to revive the team’s fortunes.

Scholes Warns: Man United May Have to Sell Kobbie Mainoo & Garnacho

Following United’s hard-fought 0-0 draw against Manchester City on Sunday, Scholes admitted that the squad needs major reinforcements but raised concerns over the club’s financial capacity to fund new signings.

Speaking to Premier League Productions, the midfield maestro said:
“Where is the money for new signings going to come from? Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s recent interviews were very telling—it doesn’t look like Ruben Amorim (or any new manager) will have a huge budget to work with.”

Scholes then dropped a bombshell, suggesting that Kobbie Mainoo and Alejandro Garnacho, two of United’s brightest academy stars, could be sold to raise funds:
“I have a feeling the club might consider selling these two young talents. Losing Mainoo would be a massive blow—he’s been at the club for years and represents the future.”

This comes after Ratcliffe publicly admitted that United face financial constraints and may need to implement cost-cutting measures before making new signings.

Keane Blasts United’s Attack: “Strikers Not Good Enough!”

Meanwhile, Roy Keane didn’t hold back in his assessment of United’s struggling forward line after the Manchester derby stalemate. The Irishman questioned whether Rasmus Højlund and Joshua Zirkzee are truly up to the task of leading United’s attack.

Speaking on Sky Sports, Keane said:
“United should be more dangerous in attack. The current strikers might not be the right fit, but goals can come from other areas—wide players, midfielders, even defenders. We’ve seen glimpses of that recently.”

The stats back Keane’s concerns:

• Højlund & Zirkzee have only managed 6 Premier League goals combined this season.
• United have struggled for consistency in front of goal, often relying on midfielders like Bruno Fernandes or Scott McTominay to bail them out.

What Should Man United Do This Summer?

Both legends agree that major changes are needed at Old Trafford. Here’s what the club must address:

• ✅ Decide on the Manager – Will Erik ten Hag stay, or will a new coach like Ruben Amorim take over?
• ✅ Strengthen the Attack – A proven striker must be a priority, with names like Victor Osimhen or Ivan Toney linked.
• ✅ Midfield Reinforcements – If Mainoo leaves, United will need a top-class replacement.
• ✅ Defensive Stability – Injuries have plagued the backline; a new centre-back could be crucial.
• ✅ Financial Strategy – Will Ratcliffe sanction sales to fund new arrivals?

Fans React: “Don’t Sell Our Future!”

United supporters have taken to social media to voice their frustrations, with many pleading:
“Selling Mainoo or Garnacho would be a disaster!”
“We need investment, not another rebuild.”
“If we sell our best youngsters, what’s the point of the academy?”

The summer transfer window will be make or break for Manchester United. With financial limitations and pressure to return to the top, tough decisions lie ahead. Will Ratcliffe back a major squad overhaul, or will the club be forced to cash in on their brightest talents?

What do YOU think United should do? Drop your comments below!

Follow Nigerian sport news for the latest news, transfer updates, and exclusive analysis!